Barefoot Fitness

Change the System, Not the Symptom

raindrops

For a little over a year, early in my time in the military, I had to wake up at 3:00 a.m. This was to walk to the special programs physical training (P.T.) workout that started at 3:45 on the other side of the base.

My routine was pretty robotic. I'd be out of bed as quickly as possible to silence my alarm because I had roommates who weren't involved in special programs and didn't start their day for another five hours. I'd put contacts in (I didn't get eye surgery until several years later), get dressed, drink a tiny amount of whey protein or a recovery powder, grab a small pack with a towel and goggles and be out the door by 3:14.

At 3:20 I was down five flights of stairs and waiting under a streetlight in front of my barracks for a friend. By 3:35 I was checked in, standing in line with my boat crew and waiting for the doors to open for about two hours of training.

There was close to zero wiggle room in this routine. An extra five minutes in bed would mean that my friend would fall behind schedule for the handful of minutes he might wait for me and that we would both be too late to get checked into our boat crews before the doors opened unless we ran the whole way.

The main weak point in this process was simply getting out of bed. In the middle of winter in Chicago with wind beating snow against the window at three a.m. there's not much I would have rather done than stay warm in my bed a few moments longer before trudging through a snowstorm in ridiculous UDT shorts and a hoodie to get in a pool and try not to drown.

UDT shorts
UDT shorts: Because nothing says "motivated" like khaki hot pants.

My solution to make sure I was always on time had nothing to do with an inordinate amount of willpower. I simply put my alarm clock on a shelf on the other side of the room. As soon as it went off, I had to get completely out of bed to shut it off, and I had to do it quickly in order to not be a complete asshole to my roommates. Staying in bed longer wasn't an option.

You've probably heard some of the talk lately about stand up desks and how detrimental hours of continuous sitting can be. I spend quite a bit of time on my laptop and I know that I should spend more of it standing.

My solution to this again has little to do with constantly chastising myself to stand. I just put my laptop on top of a box on my desk (plus a few books to get the right height) that's just big enough that I can't really set my laptop anywhere else but on top of it and still use it comfortably. To move my laptop, toss the books aside and move the box so that I can put my laptop back onto my desk is more annoying than to just work on it while standing, which is what I end up doing much of the time.

We all make grandiose plans for our future selves. "On Monday, I'm going to start learning a new language, working out early every morning and eating better. I'll go to that butcher shop and get grass fed beef for dinner along with my kale and blueberries. I'll watch nothing but independent films and documentaries on tv and only do that after I've re-shingled the roof."

The thing is, we never actually meet our future selves, and they'll never get around to any of the tasks we assign to them because when that projected future time rolls around it's our experiencing selves who take charge. And the last time they faced the idea of all that stuff that required willpower our current selves just dumped it on that other guy in the future.

A great example of this poor forecasting from David Mcraney is that you may have a Netflix queue with a hundred different great films that you keep telling yourself you should watch sometime, but when the moment actually comes to choose something you end up watching Jim Carrey get the suitcase to Aspen.

Harry and Lloyd

It's extremely easy to hit the snooze button or lay in bed an extra few minutes too long, but that's not likely to be remedied by just convincing yourself that tomorrow will be different. Staying in bed is a symptom of the system as a whole; a byproduct. By changing that system so that it was no longer easy to stay in bed or hit the snooze alarm, it became a non-issue.

If I had an option to sit in a nice cozy chair in front of a desk I'd probably do that, even if I was making a mental note to myself that I really should invest in a standing desk sometime. Instead, I did something easy to change the system so that in the future the path of least resistance is to do the thing that I know is better in the long run.

Take this into account when making plans, especially when those plans involve a deviation from your normal habits or doing something that requires finite willpower. Think of a drop of water. You want it to get from point A to point B. You're not going to expect the water to get there because that's what's good for it. You expect it to get there because that's where gravity will take it, and if that environment were to change, so would the path of the water.  

We're not as different from that drop of water as you may like to think. Our actual control over our future actions is limited. What can be controlled, however, is what you do right now to shape your future environment so that the path of least resistance is the one you actually want yourself to take.

 

June 25, 2012 by craig weller Post a Comment
It was tagged with change the system not the symptom, finite willpower, david mcraney, you are not so smart, gnolls.org, self discipline, behavior change, and psychology

Comments for This Entry

  1. Craig,
    Please write more often. I really enjoy your blog, but your updates are few and far between lately! Thanks.

    Posted on 12:56AM on June 26, 2012 [permalink]

  2. Nice article, Craig. 3am? Wow, that's rough. I struggle to wake up at 8am. (Don't punch me, please.)

    All joking aside, you're right about deferring to the future. I hear it constantly: "I'll quit [bad habit] next month." But we don't realize that when "next month" rolls around, we're still our current selves. Seems like something from "Stumbling on Happiness" and how we're so poor at predicting the future.

    For waking up, my current setup is this: a gentle alarm at arm's reach about five minutes before my target time. (That way, I'm not assaulted every morning.) Then, I have a blaring alarm on the other side of the room that goes off at the right time. When I turn it off, there's a question written on it, "How bad do you want to be great??"

    Works well.

    Posted on 11:13AM on June 26, 2012 [permalink]

  3. Craig,

    Another excellent post. I keep thinking my 5 o'clock alarm is bad, ( which I use same trick of putting across room) I guess there is someone always that gets up earlier. Guess 5 isnt so bad after all. Keep posting. There excellent!

    Posted on 09:40PM on June 27, 2012 [permalink]

  4. I work a 24/48 schedule. 24 hrs on, 48 hrs off. Work days start and end at 0700. I get up at 0300 every work day so that I can drive 35 miles to work out at headquarters before my shift. This allows me about 15 minutes to get out the door, 45 minutes to make the trip, an hour and a half to work out, and a half hour to get to the station, shower, and shave. I'm ready for work by 0600 every shift.

    This serves a purpose. I don't just like to be the first one there. In fact, my crew are all at work by 0630, to relieve the offgoing crew and catch any early calls so the other guys can get home or to their second jobs.

    For me, there are many opportunities every day to waste time, knowing that I've got 4 hours between the time I wake up and the time I actually have to walk in the door at work. Knowing that I'm going to be at work for at least 24 hours, and that I might not sleep much or at all during that time. My motivation is that I don't want to be a blue falcon or a clock-pusher. I belong to a brotherhood of guys that look out for each other, at least at my station. Because of that, I chose years ago to change the system. My phone is my alarm, and at night, it charges on a bedside table just out of reach while I'm in bed.

    Posted on 09:21AM on June 28, 2012 [permalink]

  5. Great article and so many implications.

    My favorite environment fail is moms that go on diets but keep junk food in the house because "it's for their kids", but then they end up eating it anyways (cuz willpower is finite....) Haha.

    Posted on 03:24PM on August 17, 2012 [permalink]

Comments are closed for this post.